Whenever modern situations become worrisome, it is nearly always instructive to peer back into history for perspective and understanding. With the crazy, off-the-wall economic policies of the current United States government, there are many historical events from which one can draw context. One such moment in time is the monarchy of Spain during the 1500s. See for yourself if there are not parallels inumerous.

Z spanish main

In the late 1400's, explorations for gold and passages to the east produced the discovery of what became known as the New World. Spain quickly edged out Portugal as the dominant player in this game throughout much of the 1500s, and literally tons of gold and silver made its way across the Atlantic from the infamous Spanish Main in Mexico, Latin and South America to the coffers in Seville, Spain. There were many unfortunate effects of this, such as the near total decimation of the Inca and Mayan native populations, as well as the instigation of the African slave trade. First the natives, and increasingly so the Africans, were needed to man the mines. As a result of this system, massive amounts of gold and silver were hauled across the Atlantic and into Europe. Some estimates say that this amount was so enormous that the total of precious metal in Europe at the end of the 1500s was more than five times what it was at the beginning of that century when the New World was discovered!
Ztreasure
It would be logical to deduce that Spain became one of the richest nations in the world as a result of this massive influx of wealth. But interestingly, and very educationally, this was not the case.

What happened?

Author Peter L. Bernstein writes:

"Once the gold began arriving in quantity, the Spanish were far more proficient at spending than at producing. The massive imports of gold and silver stimulated the spending skills at the same time that they stifled Spain's incentive to produce. Spain acted like a poor man who makes a great windfall at the gambling tables but comes to believe that the money is his destiny rather than a nonrecurring event . . . . Late in the century the . . . Parliament declared, 'The more of [gold] that comes in, the less the Kingdom has. . . Though our kingdoms should be the richest in the world . . . they are the poorest, for they are only a bridge for [the gold and silver] to go to the Kindgdoms of our enemies.' Another Spanish observer, Pedro de Valencia, wrote, 'So much silver and money . . . always has been fatal poison to  republics and cities.  They believe money will keep them and it is not true: plowed fields, pastures, and fisheries are what give sustenance.'  Gold has always been associated with power. Once the kings of Spain realized how much new wealth the discoveries of gold in the American colonies would bring them, they convinced themselves that their wealth was great enough to bend the world to their will.'"

An apt analogy would be of 'second generation wealth.' It is almost a cliche that sons squander their father's wealth, thinking that they have somehow, by eating at the same table, sleeping under the same roof, and being sufficiently 'talked at' by the patriarch, been bestowed the 'magic touch' which their father used to produce the wealth in the first place. The squandering of the father's empire in such cases is so common as to be almost a rule. This is because there is no 'touch' of greatness, nor family superiority, nor endowments or bestowed rights, there are only the laws of success. And those laws are almost immediately broken by a son taking over the reigns of a great empire for which he was not forced to labor to create nor strive to earn. The violation of the earning principle produces harsh results and even harsher lessons. Sorry golden boys.

Another comparison, and the one that inspired this article, is made to the current United States government and its hubris and arrogance in thinking it has found its own Spanish Main in the printing of free money by the Federal Reserve banking scam (er, um, I mean banking system). Having arranged for itself a tidy little sitaution in which it can produce currency out of nothing, the government has taken to acting like the monarch of sixteenth century Spain, with figurative ships laden with "bailout money" and "earmarks." Our bureaucratic government has taken leave of its senses in a 'gold fever' all its own creation, thinking it can disdain major industrial and agricultural infrastructures while gifting billions of dollars in bailouts to its partners in banking complicit in its schemes. Worse, it seems to think it can foist this on an American citizenry without ramifications, as though Americans are naive Incas or backward Mayans.

Tellingly, however, the Incas were not naive, only trusting. The Mayans were not backwards, only fooled into thinking the Spaniards were gods. Today, Americans, or at least some of them, seem to be falling into the same traps of the Incas and the Mayans: too trusting of the government, and somehow duped into believing in political messiahs. To continue such foolishness will result in the same fate as the indiginous peoples of Latin and South America; decimation.

But America cannot stand upon its stolen spending power any more than Spain could stand upon its stolen treasure. Wealth unearned bears with it a curse. Instead, as Peter Schiff said, "Consumption is made possible by production and credit is made possible by
savings."
 Government economic shenanigans are no substitute, but rather a drug taken to defer the pain until later, at which time the pain is even greater.
  
Posted in

13 responses to “The Curse of Wealth Unearned”

  1. Frank Burgett Avatar
    Frank Burgett

    You are always right on point Chris!
    Leadership Tidbits and Treasures
    is one of my favorite books and I am convinced that another book, within Orrin’s Blog and yours, is needed to advance the education of an awakening public. Because the way I see it Mr. Woodward and yourself have in fact become watchmen.
    If you do decide to put pen to paper and have a contest for the title my entry is “HEY D.C. WAKE UP! WE’RE NOT DEAD YET”
    Thanks for all you do,
    Frank

    Like

  2. Matt Ruhlman Avatar
    Matt Ruhlman

    Chris,
    Fantastic Insight! Put in the proper context it boggles the mind how people can come to these economic conclusions.
    Today I heard a news report that there is an ongoing argument between the U.S. wanting other nations to spend there way out and the Europeans want nations to regulate there way out…the only thing I could think to hope for is a staalmate.
    I know you couldn’t presume to know what is in others hearts but how much of this madness is do to ignorance and how much is malicious?
    Thank you for your perspective.

    Like

  3. Phyllis Hoff Avatar
    Phyllis Hoff

    Chris:
    This post reminds me of the passion I heard in your CD The Second Second. I love that CD.
    You compared the side affects of one drug that then leads to another, instead of letting the body heal.
    Your last sentence about the government defering the pain until later, at which time the pain is even greater is definitely what is happening. The pain is greater and growing.
    Your determination on that CD was amazing. I am so glad that there are men like you and the TEAM leaders who will stand up for truth.
    God Bless

    Like

  4. Cathy Avatar
    Cathy

    Chris,
    I am a poster child for what happens when first hand poor marries new comfortability, and produces second generation disaster. Only in my case, I was both the poor child and the disaster!
    When I was a young bride, I married a man who was better off financially than my parents. My parents struggled all their lives to provide for the 5 of us kids, all on my father’s blue collar salary.
    I’d never had much of money of my own. All of my earned money went to stuff for my car or my college tuition, which I had to pay for myself. Any extra, I spent. I never learned good saving habits. I just didn’t know any better. I was also an emotional spender, a fault I work to overcome even today.
    My new husband worked in a white collar job, and had been working in it for several years prior to our marriage. His parents had paid for his college education, and he’d been frugal in his post-college lifestyle. So when we met and married, he’d accummulated a tidy nest egg, with which we put down the downpayment on the house in which I now sit.
    Ignorance + emotional spending married frugality + savings + higher standard of living. Unfortunately, I learned the difference over the course of many years between these polar opposites, and the lessons were always expensive.
    In the past few weeks, I’ve listened to the CD’s of the Finances Pack at least twice. I am getting ready to listen to the older version, the Wealth Thinking Pack now. Because I figure if poor thinking got us into our mess, than good thinking will likely get us out . . .
    Oh, and by the way, we have one adult kid that understands the value of wealth and work. And another one who doesn’t, and thinks Mom and Dad are walking, talking ATM’s . . .

    Like

  5. Paul Windemuller Avatar
    Paul Windemuller

    Chris,
    I have just finished reading Thomas Paine’s “Common Sense”. In it he talked about how 1776 was the time that Americans needed to take action against English rule. He made many good points on why it was important for the colonists to act now before all was lost and the opportunity for the greatest country in the world was lost. I see a lot of parallels from that book for the situation that is before us in America today. NOW is the time to act! We must fight against mediocrity before the greastest country the world has ever seen is lost!
    Thanks for the knowledge that you gift us with to know the truth. Thank you for giving me a hunger to learn from the classics by people like Thomas Paine, Adam Smith, and our Founding Fathers.
    All is not yet lost!
    God Bless

    Like

  6. Dave in FL Avatar
    Dave in FL

    Hi Chris;
    Which president ruined something?
    Kennedy-Johnson ruined our military and split our country in Vietnam.
    Nixon was dishonest-got caught.
    Bush-1 took us back to War. What did we win?
    Clinton-adultery and lying-congress made him not responsible for his actions.
    Bush-2 took us from 9-11 to Financial crazyness and back to War.
    Obama-continued the Bush Financial crazyness and continued WAR.
    Does any recent President have a clue? I doubt it.

    Like

  7. Cathy Avatar
    Cathy

    Chris,
    Here’s a Wednesday funny for you from my email . . .

    A cowboy named Bud was overseeing his herd in a remote mountainous pasture in California when suddenly a brand new BMW advanced out of a dust cloud towards him.
    The driver, a young man in a Brioni suit, Gucci shoes, RayBan sunglasses and YSL tie, leans out the window and asks the cowboy, ‘If I tell you exactly how many cows and calves you have in your herd, Will you give me a calf?’
    Bud looks at the man, obviously a yuppie, then looks at his peacefully grazing herd and calmly answers, Sure, Why not?’
    The yuppie parks his car, whips out his Dell notebook computer, connects it to his Cingular RAZR V3 cellphone, and surfs to a NASA page on the Internet, where he calls up a GPS satellite to get an exact fix on his location which he then feeds to another NASA satellite that scans the area in an ultra-high-resolution photo.
    The young man then opens the digital photo in Adobe Photoshop and exports it to an image processing facility in Hamburg, Germany
    Within seconds, he receives an email on his Palm Pilot that the image has been processed and the data stored. He then accesses a MS-SQL database through an ODBC connected Excel spreadsheet with email on his Blackberry and, after a few minutes, receives a response.
    Finally, he prints out a full-color, 150-page report on his hi-tech, miniaturized HP LaserJet printer and finally turns to the cowboy and says, ‘You have exactly, 586 cows and calves.’
    ‘That’s right. Well, I guess you can take one of my calves,’ says Bud.
    He watches the young man select one of the animals and looks on amused as the young man stuffs it into the trunk of his car.
    Then Bud says to the young man, ‘Hey, if I can tell you exactly what your business is, will you give me back my calf?’
    The young man thinks about it for a second and then says, Okay, why not?’
    ‘You’re a Congressman for the U.S. Government’, says Bud.
    ‘Wow! That’s correct,’ says the yuppie, ‘but how did you guess that?’
    ‘No guessing required.’ answered the cowboy. ‘You showed up here even though nobody called you; you want to get paid for an answer I already knew, to a question I never asked. You tried to show me how much smarter than me you are; and you don’t know a thing about cows…this is a herd of sheep. . .
    Now give me back my dog.

    Like

  8. Chris schill Avatar
    Chris schill

    Thanks, awesome article!

    Like

  9. Jason Hobson Avatar
    Jason Hobson

    Chris,
    I have come enjoy reading your thoughts and how that they so naturally flow into our lives. This latest entry is no exception.
    Why is it that the second-generation feel that they “deserve” what their parents “WORKED” so hard for? Sadly, I think it may be almost a self inflicted wound. This isn’t across the board, but it seems so many parents that have made enough of a living for themselves, whether self-employed or an employee feel that it is their responsibility to make their children’s life better than that which they had. Now I’m not saying that you should give your kids a spoon and tell them to go shovel coal in the mine. But, why is it that we feel that our children shouldn’t have to work as hard as we did? That we feel we should make our children’s lives “easy” for them? That life is best served on a silver platter, when everything is handed to you? No. Don’t you worry; I don’t want you to strain yourself to get that. Let me slide that right up to the double chin of mediocrity and the side of complacency that your listlessness body is lounging in.
    Did that hard work, make us appreciate the rewards that much more?
    Did that hard work really have any detrimental affects on our lives? More likely No!
    Our society has seemingly forgotten the lost art of hard work.
    Hard work built Ford, General Motors, and Chevrolet.
    Hard Work, created the food that our country eats and distributes throughout the world.
    Hard Work, has been what has driven inspiration, innovation and invention.
    Hard Work, is the back bone of our country!
    When we lose sight of even one of the principles that made our country great, the other principles will be right behind them in line for the guillotine. When “Hard Work” is buried in the cemetery, the pall bearers, Honesty, Integrity, Character, Fortitude, Love, and Wisdom, will gravely look upon his tomb and wonder which one of them will be the next one sacrificed in the name of progress.
    These principles are the bedrock of our society. Too bad our government thinks that they are just speed bumps on the road to the future.
    We are the hope for the future. We are the patriots who will stand for freedom. We are the warriors who will battle mediocrity and complacency.
    God Speed.
    Jason Hobson

    Like

  10. Brandon Marken Avatar

    Chris, I always appreciate your utilization of history as an analog to examine current economic practices. I heard Jennifer granholm say something intelligent once, haha, she said, WE shouldn’t look in the rear view mirror except to learn.” Does it concern you that our media and society have completely ignored the fact that the federal government just forced the CEO of GM to resign. I didn’t know that was their role! Thomas Sowell always has interesting insight to these issues, do you ever read his blog?

    Like

  11. George Lucas Avatar
    George Lucas

    Chris,
    I was suprised today to read in an update on the mark to market regulations a comment by one of the attendees. They relaxed the regulations for banks. His comment was – you don’t correct the temperature in a cold room by holding a candle to the thermometer. Apparently those who voted to relax the regulations still don’t get what is wrong with the business world.

    Like

  12. John Dickinson - Team One Purpose! Avatar

    Chris,
    It looks like the conveyor belt school system I was on when I was younger forgot to teach me this!
    Thanks!
    John

    Like

  13. Ian Avatar
    Ian

    Fantastic article Chris!

    Like

Leave a reply to Cathy Cancel reply